When Family Hurts: How to Recognize Toxic Relationships and Protect Your Mental Health

11/22/2024

Personal Experiences With Boundaries

I often normalize the idea of learning about boundaries at any age with my clients, especially when I see the relief it brings them. I remember my own experience with boundaries, which didn’t happen until graduate school. I was in therapy, navigating the complexities of my own life, when my therapist said something that completely shifted my perspective: "You have the right to set rules in relationships. All types of relationships—romantic, friendships, and even with family."

I remember how that statement made me feel. It was as if a light bulb had gone off in my head, but the glow felt almost too bright at first. I had always believed that relationships should be fluid and that I should adjust to others’ needs, often at the expense of my own. But hearing that I had the right to define the terms of my relationships was both empowering and liberating. It was like discovering a tool I had never been taught about, one that could help me protect my energy and well-being. In that moment, I realized that setting boundaries wasn’t selfish—it was essential for my mental health.

It’s something I share with my clients today because I know how transformative that realization can be. Boundaries are not just rules for others; they’re the way we take care of ourselves. And sometimes, we don’t realize we have the right to set them until someone points it out.

Family relationships are deeply personal, and can be very complex. Over the years, I’ve come to understand this from both personal experience and through my work with clients. As a creative person, I’ve often faced moments where my passions and unique way of seeing the world weren’t fully understood by those closest to me. And in today’s rapidly changing political and social landscape, I’ve also felt the tension that can arise when core beliefs don’t align, even within family.

These experiences have given me insight into just how difficult it can be to balance maintaining family connections with protecting your mental health. It’s also one of the questions I get asked most often in my work: "How do I navigate an unhealthy family relationship, especially when we see the world so differently?"

I wanted to dedicate this article to exploring that question. My hope is that it provides clarity, validation, and actionable steps for anyone grappling with these challenges. You’re not alone in this, and there are ways to approach these situations that honor both your mental health and the complexities of family. Let’s dive in.

When Family Relationships Become Unhealthy: Recognizing the Signs and Taking Action

Family relationships are often a cornerstone of emotional support and stability. However, they can also become a source of stress and harm when dynamics turn unhealthy. Understanding when a family relationship begins to negatively impact your mental health is vital for your well-being. In this article, we’ll explore how to recognize the signs of an unhealthy family relationship and steps you can take to address it.

Signs of an Unhealthy Family Relationship

1. Constant Criticism or Blame
   If a family member consistently criticizes you, belittles your achievements, or places undue blame on you, it can erode your self-esteem and create feelings of inadequacy.

2. Emotional Manipulation
   Manipulative behaviors, such as guilt-tripping, gaslighting, or withholding affection, are clear indicators of a toxic dynamic. These tactics can leave you doubting yourself and feeling trapped.

3. Lack of Respect for Boundaries
   Healthy relationships honor personal boundaries. If a family member disregards your limits—be it time, privacy, or emotional space—it can lead to feelings of suffocation or resentment.

4. Unresolved Conflicts
   When conflicts are frequent and never resolved, it creates a tense and hostile environment. Over time, this tension can significantly affect your mental health.

5. One-Sided Effort
   Relationships require mutual effort. If you’re always the one reaching out, making amends, or supporting the other person, it can leave you feeling drained and undervalued.

6. Physical or Verbal Abuse
   Abuse in any form is a clear sign of an unhealthy relationship. This includes not only physical harm but also verbal aggression that undermines your sense of safety and self-worth.

The Impact on Mental Health

Unhealthy family relationships can lead to:
- Chronic stress and anxiety
- Feelings of guilt or shame
- Difficulty concentrating or sleeping
- Depression or a sense of hopelessness
- Isolation from other supportive relationships

couple arguing at table inside | how to recognize signs of unhealthy family relationships and what to do about it, by therapist Cindy Cisneros, LCPC-S

What to Do When a Relationship Becomes Unhealthy

1. Acknowledge the Problem
   The first step is to recognize and admit the impact the relationship is having on your mental health. This can be a difficult realization, especially with family, but it’s essential for taking action.

2. Set Clear Boundaries
   Communicate your needs and establish boundaries with the family member. For example, let them know specific behaviors that are unacceptable and the consequences of crossing those lines.

3. Seek Support
   Talk to a trusted friend, or therapist. Having an outside perspective can provide clarity and emotional support during this time.

4. Limit Contact
   If the relationship continues to be harmful despite your efforts, consider reducing or even cutting contact. While this can be a tough decision, protecting your mental health is paramount. Read on if you are considering this option.

5. Focus on Self-Care
   Engage in activities that bring you joy and relaxation. Prioritizing your mental and physical well-being can help you recover from the emotional toll of an unhealthy relationship.

6. Explore Family Counseling
   If both parties are willing, family counseling can be a constructive way to address the issues and rebuild a healthier dynamic.

When to Walk Away

There are situations where maintaining a relationship, even with family, is not in your best interest. If the relationship involves persistent abuse, manipulation, or neglect, it may be healthier to distance yourself entirely. Remember, choosing to step back from a harmful relationship doesn’t mean you don’t care—it means you care enough about yourself to prioritize your mental health.

Unhealthy Relationships Wrap-up

Family relationships can be both deeply rewarding and profoundly challenging. Recognizing when a relationship has become unhealthy and taking proactive steps to address it is essential for your mental well-being. Whether it involves setting boundaries, seeking therapy, or stepping away, remember that your mental health matters, and it’s okay to prioritize yourself.

By taking these steps, you’re not only protecting your mental health but also opening the door to healthier and more supportive relationships in the future. And remember, you have permission to adjust and readjust boundaries at any time. To learn more, read on.

creative person sitting outside against tree holding red pillow | what to do when family misunderstands you as a creative, an article by Cindy Cisneros, LCPC-S

When Family Members Misunderstand You as a Creative Person

For those who identify as creative, family relationships can become particularly complex. Creativity is often deeply personal, and being misunderstood by loved ones can feel isolating and invalidating. These misunderstandings might not be intentional, but they can still impact your mental health.

Common Misunderstandings Creatives Face in Families

1. Devaluing Creative Work
   Family members may not see your creative pursuits as "real work," especially if they don’t align with traditional career paths. This can lead to dismissive comments or lack of support for your professional goals.

2. Pressure to Conform
   Creatives often think outside the box, but family members may push you toward more conventional choices. This pressure to "fit in" can stifle your creativity and create feelings of inadequacy.

3. Misjudging Emotional Sensitivity
   Many creative people are naturally more in tune with their emotions, which might be labeled as being "too sensitive" or "overly dramatic" by family members who don’t understand this trait.

4. Underestimating the Importance of Creativity
   Creativity isn’t just a hobby; for many, it’s a vital part of their identity and mental health. Family members who don’t grasp this might not understand why creative expression is essential for your well-being.

How These Misunderstandings Affect Mental Health

When family members fail to understand or support your creativity, it can lead to:
- Feeling undervalued or invisible
- Questioning your identity and passions
- Difficulty setting boundaries with loved ones
- Internalizing criticism, which may stifle your creative output

What to Do When You Feel Misunderstood

1. Communicate Your Perspective
   Share how important your creative work is to you and why it matters for your mental health. Use specific examples to illustrate how it brings you joy, fulfillment, or stability.

2. Find a Supportive Community
   Seek out other creatives who understand your journey. This could be through local groups, online communities, or professional networks where your creativity is appreciated and validated.

3. Set Boundaries
   Protect your creative time and energy by setting clear boundaries with family members who may unintentionally drain or discourage you. For instance, you might say, “I need this time to focus on my art; let’s talk later.”

4. Celebrate Your Wins
   Even if your family doesn’t fully understand, take pride in your creative achievements. Share them with those who do appreciate your work, or keep a personal record to remind yourself of your progress.

5. Practice Self-Compassion
   Remember, being misunderstood doesn’t diminish the value of your creativity. Treat yourself with kindness and remind yourself that your passion is valid, even if not everyone sees it.

6. Consider Professional Help
   If feeling misunderstood by family is causing significant distress, a therapist or creativity coach can help you navigate these challenges and reinforce your sense of self-worth.

Creatively Misunderstood Wrap-up

Family misunderstandings can be painful, but they don’t define your creative journey. By asserting your needs, finding like-minded support, and focusing on your mental health, you can thrive despite these challenges. Remember, your creativity is a gift—not just for the world, but for yourself. Embrace it fully, even if not everyone understands.

Giving Yourself Permission to Reassess and Readjust Boundaries

As you heal and evolve, your needs, priorities, and capacity for relationships can change. This growth often necessitates revisiting and readjusting the boundaries you’ve set with family members. It’s important to give yourself permission to reassess these dynamics without guilt or hesitation.

Why Reassessing Boundaries Is Essential

1. Personal Growth Requires Change
   Healing and self-discovery often lead to a deeper understanding of what you need to thrive. Boundaries that worked in the past may no longer serve your mental health or align with your values.

2. Family Dynamics May Shift
   Over time, family members may change their behavior or develop a better understanding of your perspective. This can create opportunities to adjust boundaries to foster healthier interactions—or reinforce limits if patterns remain harmful.

3. Your Capacity Fluctuates
   Life circumstances, energy levels, and emotional resilience vary. Being flexible with boundaries allows you to protect your well-being during challenging times and engage more fully when you feel ready.

How to Reassess and Readjust Boundaries

1. Evaluate What’s Working and What’s Not
   Reflect on your current boundaries. Are they protecting your mental health, or do they feel restrictive or ineffective? Pay attention to how you feel during and after interactions with family members.

2. Acknowledge Your Healing Progress
   Recognize the growth and strength you’ve gained. This perspective can help you determine whether you’re ready to adjust boundaries or maintain the current distance.

3. Communicate Changes Clearly
   If you decide to adjust boundaries, be direct and compassionate when communicating with your family. For example:
   - “I’m in a better place now and would like to reconnect more often.”
  - “I still need some space, but I value our relationship and hope we can work toward healthier communication.”

4. Check In With Yourself Regularly
   Healing is not linear, and what feels right today may not tomorrow. Periodically reassess your boundaries to ensure they continue to support your evolving needs.

5. Don’t Be Afraid to Reinforce Boundaries
   If a family member crosses a boundary or reverts to harmful behavior, it’s okay to step back again. Healing is a journey, and protecting your mental health should remain a priority.

Overcoming Guilt When Adjusting Boundaries

Many people struggle with guilt when changing family dynamics, especially if their choices are met with resistance. To counter this:
- Remind yourself of your worth: Your needs are valid, and prioritizing your mental health benefits everyone involved in the long run.
- Focus on the bigger picture: Healthy boundaries create stronger, more sustainable relationships.
- Seek validation elsewhere: Surround yourself with supportive people who understand and affirm your choices.

Readjusting Boundaries Wrap-up

Reassessing and readjusting boundaries is not only a natural part of healing but also a powerful act of self-care. It reflects your growth, self-awareness, and commitment to maintaining healthy relationships on your terms. Remember, boundaries are not permanent—they’re flexible tools to protect your peace and foster connection where it’s possible and safe. Give yourself permission to adapt as you continue to heal and evolve.

Navigating Family Divides Over Politics, Religion, or Beliefs

Differences in politics, religion, or deeply held beliefs can create significant tension in family relationships. These divides often feel especially painful because they touch on core values and identity. However, it’s possible to approach these differences in ways that protect your mental health while maintaining or redefining family connections.

Signs the Divide Is Impacting Your Mental Health

1. Frequent Arguments
   Conversations repeatedly turn into debates or heated disagreements, leaving you emotionally drained or stressed.

2. Feeling Invalidated or Attacked
   Family members may dismiss your beliefs, use derogatory language, or refuse to respect your perspective.

3. Avoiding Family Gatherings
   You might dread interactions with family because of anticipated conflicts or judgment about your values.

4. Struggling With Self-Doubt
   Constant criticism or pressure to conform can lead you to question your beliefs or suppress your identity.

Strategies for Managing Political or Religious Divides

1. Acknowledge Differences Without Seeking Agreement
   It’s okay to accept that your beliefs may never align. Instead of trying to change each other’s minds, focus on finding common ground or agreeing to disagree respectfully.

   For example:
   - “I see this issue differently, but I value our relationship and want to focus on what connects us.”

2. Set Conversation Boundaries
   Politely but firmly limit discussions on contentious topics if they repeatedly lead to conflict.

You might say:
   - “I’d prefer not to talk about politics today. Let’s focus on catching up about other things.”

3. Lean Into Shared Values
   Even if your beliefs differ, there may be shared values—such as family, kindness, or helping others—that can form the foundation of your interactions.

4. Distance Yourself When Necessary
   If interactions consistently leave you upset or anxious, it’s okay to limit contact. You can still express love and care while stepping back from divisive conversations.

   For example:
   - “I care about you, but I need some space right now to focus on my well-being.”

5. Engage With Like-Minded Communities
   Surrounding yourself with people who share your beliefs can help you feel supported and less isolated. Whether through friends, online groups, or local organizations, finding a sense of belonging is vital.

6. Practice Empathy While Holding Firm
   Understanding where your family’s beliefs come from doesn’t mean you have to agree or compromise your own. You can empathize with their experiences while staying true to yourself.

What to Do When Respect Is Absent

If family members are unwilling to respect your boundaries or repeatedly attack your beliefs, consider:
- Limiting contact: Reduce time spent with those who refuse to engage respectfully.
- Focusing on relationships that uplift you: Invest energy in family members who support your individuality, even if they don’t share your views.
- Seeking outside support: A therapist can help you process these conflicts and develop strategies for coping.

male presenting person seated on couch hand over face | how to manage political and/or religious differences in families, tips by a creative therapist Cindy Cisneros, LCPC-S

Political or Religious Divide Wrap-up

Divides over politics, religion, or beliefs can test even the closest family bonds. By setting clear boundaries, focusing on mutual respect, and protecting your mental health, you can navigate these challenges while staying true to yourself. Remember, it’s okay to prioritize your peace over maintaining harmony at any cost. Family relationships thrive when built on mutual understanding and respect, and it’s never wrong to seek those qualities in your connections.

Free Consult

Conclusion: Prioritizing Your Mental Health in Family Relationships

Family relationships can be a source of love and support, but they can also challenge your mental health when boundaries are crossed or misunderstandings arise. Whether it’s navigating toxic dynamics, being misunderstood as a creative person, dealing with political or religious divides, or evolving in your own healing journey, the key is to prioritize your well-being and approach these challenges with intention.

Recognizing the signs of an unhealthy relationship is the first step toward protecting your peace. From setting clear boundaries to reassessing them as you grow, it’s important to give yourself permission to adapt to your needs. Misunderstandings—whether about your creativity, values, or identity—don’t diminish your worth, and it’s okay to create distance when necessary to foster healthier interactions.

Ultimately, protecting your mental health in family relationships isn’t about severing ties or proving who’s right. It’s about creating space for your growth, honoring your individuality, and ensuring your relationships support the person you are becoming. By being mindful, assertive, and compassionate—both toward yourself and your family—you can navigate these challenges and build connections that enhance, rather than harm, your mental and emotional well-being.

If you’re struggling with these difficult family dynamics, you don’t have to go through it alone. At Creatively, LLC, I specialize in concierge counseling tailored to support creative individuals like you as you navigate these complex issues. Whether it’s redefining boundaries, working through misunderstandings, or finding peace during challenging times, I’m here to help. Let’s work together to create a path forward that prioritizes your mental health and honors your unique journey. Reach out today to learn how I can support you during these difficult times.